or Connect
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Pork shoulder picnic

post #1 of 10
Thread Starter 
Pork shoulder, to remove the skin or not to remove the skin. That is the question. And....... Go! Thanks guys and gals.
post #2 of 10

I prefer to remove the skin and trim relatively lean, leaving just a very thin layer of fat just to add to the formation/texture of the bark. You can get a lot more smoke to the meat, as well as that coveted bark when you remove the skin.

 

 

 

 

 

No-foil, towel-covered resting on an elevated rack to preserve that fantastic bark:

 

 

 

What can I say...I love a heavy, crisp bark on pulled pork.

 

The above pics are from my most recent picnic shoulder smoke with wet-to-dry smoke chamber method:

http://www.smokingmeatforums.com/t/141692/picnic-shoulder-wet-to-dry-smoke-chamber-q-view-prep-method-finished

 

 

Eric

post #3 of 10

Yeah, you could season that thing for a week with the skin on and it wouldn't penetrate. Many now will remove most of the fat & all skin and apply that heavy overnight rub. Last time I did one I took a disposable pie tin, punched holes all along the bottom and put the fat in that & on the rack above to slowly ooze out and baste the meat below. Worked pretty well...Willie

post #4 of 10
Thread Starter 
Thanks for the tips guys. I absolutely love this forum.
post #5 of 10
Quote:
Originally Posted by tastywilbur83 View Post

Thanks for the tips guys. I absolutely love this forum.

 

You're welcome. You might love this place now, but in a year or so, after considering or completing tons of smoker mods, and looking at your burgeoning "must smoke" list, you may just hate this place...LOL!!! All joking aside, I can't think of any place I'd rather spend my spare time than right here...smoke and learn...help others learn...doesn't get any better, IMHO.

 

 

Eric

post #6 of 10
Quote:
Originally Posted by forluvofsmoke View Post
 

 

You're welcome. You might love this place now, but in a year or so, after considering or completing tons of smoker mods, and looking at your burgeoning "must smoke" list, you may just hate this place...LOL!!! All joking aside, I can't think of any place I'd rather spend my spare time than right here...smoke and learn...help others learn...doesn't get any better, IMHO.

 

 

Eric

Ditto - I love learning on here. I sometimes read so much that it all runs together until I can't keep track no more. Eventually it sinks in slowly, then after a couple weeks I'll have an "idea" about something and thinks it's mine/original! LOL Maybe there's some "inception" going on. Also, can you elaborate on the towel resting period? I always hate how the bark softens inside the foil.

 

As for the shoulder, skin off, save for cracklins.

post #7 of 10
Quote:
Originally Posted by Humdinger View Post
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by forluvofsmoke View Post
 

 

You're welcome. You might love this place now, but in a year or so, after considering or completing tons of smoker mods, and looking at your burgeoning "must smoke" list, you may just hate this place...LOL!!! All joking aside, I can't think of any place I'd rather spend my spare time than right here...smoke and learn...help others learn...doesn't get any better, IMHO.

 

 

Eric

Ditto - I love learning on here. I sometimes read so much that it all runs together until I can't keep track no more. Eventually it sinks in slowly, then after a couple weeks I'll have an "idea" about something and thinks it's mine/original! LOL Maybe there's some "inception" going on. Also, can you elaborate on the towel resting period? I always hate how the bark softens inside the foil.

 

As for the shoulder, skin off, save for cracklins.

 

It's outlined in the link I posted above (post #12) with the pics of the picnic:

www.smokingmeatforums.com/t/141692/picnic-shoulder-wet-to-dry-smoke-chamber-q-view-prep-method-finished

 

Oh, soft bark just doesn't get it done for me, either...the fix for it is pretty simple though...just rest on an elevated grate in a baking or roasting pan, cover with a clean towel and give it a couple hours to take a nap. Without foiling, and nothing in contact with the meat while resting except the small area of the grate, it allows the bark to breathe while resting...it reduces water vapor from collecting on the surface and basically steaming the bark and softening it up before you pull your pork. I like to leave my probe inserted during resting, as they won't hold temp quite as long as when foiled and towel-wrapped for insulation, but most larger cuts like a whole picnic or butt will hold well above 140*  for over 2 hours. The only draw-back to this resting method is that you have about 2/3-3/4 as long of a window for a time-buffer when resting before you need to get it pulled and served or chilled, so you need to get it finished a little closer on timing if you're on a dead-line for your meal...that said, the window isn't that much smaller, IMHO.

 

A quote from the finished pulled pork post (#14) in above linked thread:

Results of the resting were very good, with temps still @ 151* after 2.5 hours of resting, and that was @ room temp of around 74-75*, so your mileage may vary, but 3 hours might still be a viable length of time to rest and still be well above 140*.

 

The towel-covered, elevated resting for pulled pork subjects really helps preserve your bark. I've been doing that for over a year now (maybe close to 18 months) with all of my pulled pork. I've used it for a few cuts of beef as well...with anything I want to keep the bark very prominent. Give it a shot...you should notice a big difference, especially if you use a dry smoke chamber to set the bark for several hours, or at least a couple, before you yank it out to rest....those two methods combined have resulted in the best bark I've ever had.

 

That soft, sometimes mushy bark just wasn't turning my crank and got very annoying to me about 2 years ago...it was time to find a way to do something about it...turned out to be nothing more than simple physics, and the rest has been very tasty history, indeed.

 

BTW, forgot to mention about saving the skin for cracklins...good catch!!!

 

 

Eric

post #8 of 10
Eric,
Thanks for the details on maintaining the bark. I might give that a try soon here. Got three butts in the freezer and they are taking up too much space!
post #9 of 10

Any time...happy to help. That's probably a good sign to get a smoke going soon if the freezer is getting too full...LOL!!!

 

 

Eric

post #10 of 10
Quote:
Originally Posted by forluvofsmoke View Post
 

 

You're welcome. You might love this place now, but in a year or so, after considering or completing tons of smoker mods, and looking at your burgeoning "must smoke" list, you may just hate this place...LOL!!! All joking aside, I can't think of any place I'd rather spend my spare time than right here...smoke and learn...help others learn...doesn't get any better, IMHO.

 

 

Eric

x2  Well said Eric.

 

   Mike

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Meat Selection and Processing