First pulled pork, question on time (and some pics)

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

swedishdan

Newbie
Original poster
Apr 2, 2013
5
10
Southern Sweden
Hi!

So, my second smoke was a butt (well, something like it anyway, cuts are slightly different in Sweden) and overall it was great, except for the time it took to finish. It was a small piece, slightly more than 2 pounds and after 8 hours in the smoker at 230-260 I had to finish it off in the oven for another 40 mins at 300. And even then it did not pull as nicely as some I've done in the dutch oven or slowcooker before. I'd have expected it to finish in 4 or 5 hours according to what I've read here. Any insight into what might be happening? Or am I simply being too impatient?

I had a bit of problem to keep a steady temp, as seems to be norm for a new WSM but it did keep between 230 and 260, with an ocational spike to 300 or so. I opened it up after 2 hours and then roughly every hour to check the temp (as I only have one oven thermometer which I used to monitor the smoker temp). 

Some pictures:


All rubbed and ready to go!


5 hours into the smoke


Finished! And I made some bread while waiting.


And pulled. There was some resitance left in, probably should have left it another 45 mins to an hour, but had to feed a hungry family...
 
Are you sure the thermometer you used to measure your smoker temp is accurate?
It really seems that you were cooking at a much lower temp than you thought.
 
Did it taste good? 

Do you know what cut of meat you used?  Some cuts may not pull apart as well as others.  Also, what most people call a butt is actually the pigs shoulder. 
 
@S2K9K: I'm fairly sure of the thermometer, it's new and I checked it using my mouth and boiling water, both readings was correct. Also the thermometer on the WSM showed roughly the same temps. Then again, obviously something is off and temp seems the logical culprit. Ahh well, as good a reason as any to try again next weekend :-)

@Rhino: yes it tasted good, and it was a shoulder piece, just not sure which part of the shoulder. It was a bit less fatty than typical.
 
Dan, it looks like it turned out good, congrats on a successful smoke...although that does seem like a long time to cook a 2 pound butt.
 
Yeah, I guess it have to be the temp. The weight I'm sure of, but perhaps I managed to measure temp wrong somehow. Seems a bit odd that I managed to get a new WSM to smoke at significantly below 225, but who knows. Try, try again :)

thanks everyone!
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky