Masterbuilt Electric Smoker "Now at Sam's Club"

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
I understand.  I am sure some folks will go out to look and buy.  It will be interesting to see if the problems are fixed.  
 
I think the newer unit with the big glass door was the one with all the problems. This unit is the older unit which I guess was/is more reliable.
 
Those are actually pics of the gen 1. Its the 20070211 which was a nice unit with 1200 watt element. Beats the hell out of the gen 2 IMHO.
 
Last edited:
Guess they may have gotten their issues with the factory addressed?  They had pulled the new models from both of the Sam's Clubs near me.  Time will tell though.  So who's going to be the first to test one?  Of if someone who has the original 2012 model happens to be in a Sam's in the near future, how about looking it over to see if you can notice any changes.

Also was the price the same as it was higher on BPS and Cabela's websites if I recall correctly.
 
IF I was in the market for an electric smoker, Masterbuilt would be at the top of the list.  For a smoker to avoid.  Prior models seem to have been very reliable. But lately too many problems to risk spending money on one. If Masterbuilt would, on their website, offer an explanation as to what went wrong and that the problems have been addressed and all is well, I might be tempted.  IF I was in the market for an electric smoker.
 
I have come to the conclusion that average 'purchaser' will have zero knowledge of smoking and even less knowledge of the previous issues that the MES has plagued owners with...I only thought that people might want to know that the MES is, once again, available at Sam's Club! The rhetoric that may be included with one's purchase of the MES is (as with all purchases) on one's own discretion. While issue that the MES may have is addressed remains to be seen. I wish nothing but the best Q come forth from said machine. It has been proven it is possible!

Controversy is great water cooler conversation, but proof requires hands on and an 'in the trenches' experience!

Happy Smokin' (whatever it is we smoke one!),

~Brett
 
People will only buy stuff that does not work for so long before looking elsewhere.   Sad, but I think we might be witnessing the slow demise of Masterbuilt as we know it.
 
If the one pictured (gen 1 unit) is indeed what is now selling at Sam's Club, that's great news. That is the tried and true design that has worked so well for many people here for years.
 
Yeah, I was on the verge of buying a MES because the little $99 Brinkman I have is too small to put as much as I'd like in there but after spending a month reading, here mostly, but other places too, the problems that come with the MES and most other affordable smokers are just to many for me to justify taking the chance. I have no patience dealing with customer service and excuses. So, I'm investing in some fireplace rope and some heat sealant and I'm going to perfect a little cheapy that's only problem is size.  I'll probably use this thing until it falls apart, by then hopefully, someone out there will have perfected a smoker that doesn't cost as much as a small car and doesn't fall apart or require rebuilding.  Until reading here, I was unaware that things such as gasket rope and heat sealant existed.  :)

While I know perfection is the goal and even though the thermostat in this thing is way off and says it doesn't get over 200 degrees, the internal thermometer I use tells me all I need to know. If I crank it to the max it gets the meat cooked in a timely manner and turning it down prolongs the cooking process for pulled pork and slower cooked meats. It puts out a ton of smoke (unfortunately a lot of it goes out the cracks but I'm working on that) and as far as I can tell, that's what it is all about.  
 
I got my MES 30 and my MES 40 both from Cabelas, and I love them both.

I don't know about the new ones, but the ones like mine that people have had problems with seem to mostly be from Sam's Club.

They even have their own model numbers, probably because old "Wally" has a direct deal with China to make theirs more cheaply.

Bear
 
Guess they may have gotten their issues with the factory addressed?  They had pulled the new models from both of the Sam's Clubs near me.  Time will tell though.  So who's going to be the first to test one?  Of if someone who has the original 2012 model happens to be in a Sam's in the near future, how about looking it over to see if you can notice any changes.

Also was the price the same as it was higher on BPS and Cabela's websites if I recall correctly. See all at: http://bestsmokersinfo.com/best-electric-smoker-reviews/

That post is over 4 years old. Maybe you could do a search for more current posts.
 
Last edited:
Yep, 4 years old and several generations later MES is still on the market.....  And there are a ton of owners in this forum.
 
 
Yep, 4 years old and several generations later MES is still on the market.....  And there are a ton of owners in this forum.
So True! 
icon14.gif


They keep chugging along.

Bear
 
For what it maybe worth... be aware MES probably has 25-30 models at any one time. A few main models and all sorts of small variations for all outlets of their units. I found I had to do real research for each store and "sale". The model you see at one store may look like the same one you find "cheaper" down the street but check the specs and features.

I bought mine (version two) as I had  done my research - mostly on MSF - and read the pluses and minuses so knew what I was looking for. My final choice was largely determined by my wild hair "MUST HAVE TODAY"!  But, I bought from a name dealer and I paid the very nominal fee for a repair package just in case.

I am very happy with my MES II. I like the remote and the glass door. I find the smoker temp readout to be way off from my Maverick and adjust the MES temp based on that reading. The AMS smoke tube provides all the smoke I want for as long as I want and I lite it with a small propane torch. I also bought a 10 g heavy duty extension cord has never failed, Bottom line... true set and forget smoking I monitor from my chair in front of the game!

I'm happy with mine....
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Clicky