Two 11 pound shoulders on the WSM - all night smoke - lots of Q-View (updated)

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

dward51

Master of the Pit
Original poster
OTBS Member
Nov 24, 2011
2,865
538
McDonough, GA
Well the wife picked up two 11+ pound pork shoulders for $0.79 a pound at Kroger the other day.  My youngest daughter came home from college and both the daughters are asking for pulled pork, so guess it's two shoulders on the WSM for me tonight. 

Only drawback is the shoulders were picnic cuts and not boston butts, but for $0.79 a pound I should not complain too much.  Probably cut between 1 and 2 pounds off each in trimming the skin, fat, etc.... but they are still 9+ pounds each.  Rubbed them down with mustard and the basic Smoke & Spice Rub.  Why Smoke & Spice?  Well that's what I had mixed in the cabinet and figured it needs to be used up as it's been there a while and I like to rotate stock.  It's a good basic rub though.

Firing up the WSM with blue bag Kingsford via a traditional minion method (3/4 ring full of unlit 4 chunks of hickory wood and will be topped off by about 2/3 a chimney of lit all over).  I will be using the water pan filled with water on this, and will also be using my DigiQ power draft to control the pit. Will be smoking at 225* for the duration.

Meat should be on the grate by about 9:20PM and should be done in time for supper tomorrow afternoon (allowing for resting in a Coleman cooler).  I will vacuum pack the leftovers and about 2/3 of it will head back to college if it survives the week (she's home on spring break next week).

Will update this with photos shortly.
 
Last edited:
As promised.....    PHOTOS!!!!!!  (more to come later)

Well, I was going to take some photos of the trimming of the picnic shoulder but the lithium battery in the camera was on it's last legs.  I did manage to get one of the rubbed meat on the WSM though.

Tonight's guests of honor - two 11pound picnic shoulders (and yes they were "enhanced" but for $0.79 a pound I'll take it)


Prepping the WSM for the traditional Minion method with hickory chunks for smoke flavor


And now the trimmed and rubbed pork shoulders are on for an all night'er smoke.  I will be using the BBQ Guru DigiQ power draft and a full water pan (yes actually using water this time).  Reason for the water is I trust the combo of water and the Guru to handle any temp spikes while I sleep and I do like my sleep (it's an old guy thing).  Water is less prone to overshoot than a clay pot base and if it does, the physics of water will tend to want to keep the temps at 212* or less (it takes a lot more energy to go from 212* water to 212* steam and it naturally wants to fall back to the liquid state without additional energy input).

I know this photo almost looks like 3 shoulders, but it's 2.  And I stood them on end (they were big) in the 18.5" WSM.

 
Last edited:
Man, those are two large & lovely hunks of pork!  It looks like its going well so far..... 
popcorn.gif
  Good luck and keep us posted.
 
Nothing wrong with Picnics. They make great PP just a little more work and loss from skin and the big bone...JJ
 
I've smoked that same picnic from Kroger and they always came out really good!! Like JJ said, a little loss but at that price who cares!!! Good to get some time with your daughters!
Will be looking for some finish pics tomorrow!
 
Well, after a restful nights sleep (while the Guru minded the pit), I checked the WSM this morning.  Temps had started to drop to 205* so it's time to reload the fire ring with charcoal.  First I set the main body aside (lid still on to conserve what heat was there). Then after knocking the ash off the remaining coals, I pushed them into a group on the side where the Guru fan was.  Then put a few more chunks of hickory in and refilled the rest of the fire ring with unlit.  The idea here is to use the remaining lit in a pile like a modified Minion method to continue the cook (like the tin can ring in the center a lot of people use).  Reassembled the WSM and after topping off the water pan with water, it's back to autopilot on the Guru.

I did manage to snap one photo of the mid-smoke meat.  Internal is around 145* when I reloaded the fire ring.  The first load ran about 30 minutes shy of 12 hours and I had enough lit to fill a quart container once I knocked the ash off and bunched them into a pile. 

And the midpoint.

 
Last edited:
Nothing wrong with some picnics...that is all we can get around here cheap.......

I hope you saved the skin to make some cracklin pellets........ would be a shame to waste that.....

Looks great so far....enjoy the time with the girls.......
 
Sigh......  I must confess I did not keep the skin.  Just did not feel like dealing with cracklings at 9PM last night.  In retrospect, I could have bagged and refrigerated them for later but I just did not really think about it.

But here is an update on the shoulders.  It's 1:30PM and they have been smoking for about 16 hours now.  Internal temp is 166* and I just hit them with my first spritz of "bark enhancer".  Today I decided to use apple juice with a little dark Karo syrup mixed in for extra sweetness and flavor complexity.  Almost put some Jack or Mark in, but for some reason decided not to (more for me that way).  I will hit them a few more times with this mixture before they are done.

You can't really see it well from this photo, but there is a foil drip pan on the lower grate.  These shoulders have not produced as much drippings as I would have expected for their size. But hey, that means more meat, right?

Just starting to form some bark on there now, but still a ways to go....

 
Last edited:
Did not brine these.  The package said they were "enhanced" and pre-brined at the factory (double check your labels as some are and some are not).

I seem to have hit that dreaded stall.  Been sitting at 165-166* for two hours now.  Guess it's time to bump the temp on the WSM a little to give it a kick as we have my in-laws coming over for supper and target time was 6:30ish.  Once again this shows the meat will be done when it's good and ready, not when you are.

Just mixed up some of SoFlaQuer's finishing sauce in squeeze bottles.  I have not tried that recipe before and this seemed like a good time.  Will post the results at the end.  Will also be making up some 5 cheese macaroni & cheese from scratch to go with the pulled pork.  Considered making fresh honey wheat rolls for buns, but the wife said just get some good buns.  Ended up buying potato buns as they have always served us well in the past.

Sorry no photo this update.   Remember if you're looking you ain't cooking....
 
Whoa!! Those look awesome. I myself am doing a shoulder right now as we speak. Lol. My wife works at the grocery store and told me there was a meat sale going on,and to get my arse down there...i showed up and all shoulders $9/ea. So I picked up a 12lber and picked up a packer brisket fot $25. Tomorrow I go back to restock while these prices last. lol.
drool.gif
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky