28 hr Butt

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

bsterk

Newbie
Original poster
Jan 9, 2013
3
10
St Petersburg, FL
First butt I smoked, turned out good, but something was wrong for it to take 28 hrs to hit 200. My first guess would be thermo, but it was a new redi chek that I had calibrated that day. Temps were:
4 - 130
6 - 150
11.5 - 165 (pretty sure this was the stall, but I was at the beach having cocktails during sunset, so I missed a 4 hr chunk of times)
14 - 167
16.5 - 171
20.5 -178
22 -180
23 -181
28 -200

Temps were pretty consistent 215-220, although I did have some issues with flare ups when adding wood. I did not wrap in foil, which probably would have helped. For the last 3-4 hrs I bumped up the temp to 240, which seemed to move temps along.

When I pulled from smoker I wrapped in foil for about 3hrs. Pork was a little dry, but thanks to SoFlaQuers finishing sauce it turned out great.

Forgot to mention it was a 10lb boneless boston butt. Rubbed and wrapped in fridge overnight, no brine, no injection.

Question is why? Was 215-220 too low of a temp? If so, where should I be for a butt (and does size change target cook temp?) If I had wrapped it at 160 would it have helped speed it along if I didn't change my cook temp?

Either way, here is a little Q-view for you.





 
First butt I smoked, turned out good, but something was wrong for it to take 28 hrs to hit 200. My first guess would be thermo, but it was a new redi chek that I had calibrated that day. Temps were:
4 - 130
6 - 150
11.5 - 165 (pretty sure this was the stall, but I was at the beach having cocktails during sunset, so I missed a 4 hr chunk of times)
14 - 167
16.5 - 171
20.5 -178
22 -180
23 -181
28 -200

Temps were pretty consistent 215-220, although I did have some issues with flare ups when adding wood. I did not wrap in foil, which probably would have helped. For the last 3-4 hrs I bumped up the temp to 240, which seemed to move temps along.

When I pulled from smoker I wrapped in foil for about 3hrs. Pork was a little dry, but thanks to SoFlaQuers finishing sauce it turned out great.

Forgot to mention it was a 10lb boneless boston butt. Rubbed and wrapped in fridge overnight, no brine, no injection.

Question is why? Was 215-220 too low of a temp? If so, where should I be for a butt (and does size change target cook temp?) If I had wrapped it at 160 would it have helped speed it along if I didn't change my cook temp?

Either way, here is a little Q-view for you.





looks great. yes your temp was to low. 225 to 250 if you are using a rub with much sugar to keep the sugar from burning. if no sugar you can go on up with the temp. i wouldn't want to go over 275. but if you must you can bring the temp up more to power thru the stall.

yes if you had wrapped it at 160 it would have gone thru the stall faster. but you wouldn't have the great bark. i like the bark so no foil  for me.

happy smoken.

David
 
Thanks for the input, I figured a higher temp was needed, but I thought keeping it steady in the 220 range would do it. I will bump it up to the 225-250 range that the mule suggested (I did have sugar in my rub, so no higher than 250 it appears). I wanted a thick, crisp bark, that was the original reason for not foiling at the stall. Next time I will kick up my temp to the 250 range to get through. Also, to all those other bark people that don't foil, do you also not foil for resting (I read fpnmf post, a pan in the oven at 170, cover the pan with foil sounds like a good option, any opinions on this method, and how long can you hold you unpulled butt in there before you start losing moisture?) It's always a learning experience everytime old smokey fires up, gotta love it. 
 
Thanks for the input, I figured a higher temp was needed, but I thought keeping it steady in the 220 range would do it. I will bump it up to the 225-250 range that the mule suggested (I did have sugar in my rub, so no higher than 250 it appears). I wanted a thick, crisp bark, that was the original reason for not foiling at the stall. Next time I will kick up my temp to the 250 range to get through. Also, to all those other bark people that don't foil, do you also not foil for resting (I read fpnmf post, a pan in the oven at 170, cover the pan with foil sounds like a good option, any opinions on this method, and how long can you hold you unpulled butt in there before you start losing moisture?) It's always a learning experience everytime old smokey fires up, gotta love it. 
I cover in a pan and leave them in the cooler covered with towels for at least an hour..

I have left them in the cooler for 3 hours and they were still hot and juicy..

"Into the cooler" reminds me of The Great Escape... I see McQueen with the baseball glove heading to the cooler..hahahahaha
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky