Smoking Disaster

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

mighty quinn

Fire Starter
Original poster
Jan 18, 2013
36
11
Sioux Falls, SD
I am writing this as a newbie to smoking hoping some of the pros can relate. I had a major smoking disaster yesterday that could have been avoided on many levels. I wanted to smoke some boneless spare ribs for a dinner at my sisters house on the other side of town. I had looked into several threads on times, temps, and techniques and felt fairly comfortable preparing the main course for this dinner. From my research, I thought that roughly 3 hours a 225 would give me a pretty good turn out, then I would sauce them, wrap them in foil, and get them over for dinner. My first and largest mistake was that stupidly on my behalf, I only gave myself 3 hours for the whole process with no room for error. I didn't account for cool down times in the smoker with chip adding or for the fact that yesterday here in South Dakota, it was about 15 degrees while I was smoking. Secondly, I left the house for about an hour and forty five minutes during the process and came home to a smoker holding at about 175. My smoker has a dial setting with no temp settings; you have to set it by dialing it in until it reads right. Needless to say, my great ribs that I had talked up to the family were refrigerated due to not being cooked through and fried chicken was served as the main course. The only good part about the experience were the lessons learned. I hope some can relate to my misfortune; I'm laughing now but was pretty upset yesterday. Thanks and good smoking!
 
YEP Had a similar situation 16 years ago. 60 guests including 3 mentor Chef's of mine, for the babies Christening, 40 pounds of Whole Shoulder and Fresh Ham in the Smoker. Totally underestimated the time and everything is ready but the Meat. Ended up cutting the huge cuts of Pork into fist size pieces and tossing Half in a 450*F Oven to finish and left the rest in the smoker, still cooking. One hour later we were eating half the meat and the rest got boxed up as Doggy Bags for everyone to take home. Embarrassing, thank God there where some much more experienced Chef's there to bail my Newbie butt out!...JJ
 
Last edited:
Just sounds like part of the learning curve Might Quinn, which will come with experience. I always allow a few extra hours than I think it will take, most smoked goodies can be foiled, wrapped in towels and put in a cooler for a few hour rest and still be piping hot for serving time.

I am just to the north of you and with yesterdays temperatures I decided to do a roast yesterday on a rotisserie indoors rather than battling -11º and 23 mph winds!
 
Mighty Quinn -- welcome to the club.  I think we all have our stories to tell.  May I recommend you keep notes from this experieince so you can correct mistakes on subsequent cooks.  Like JJ from 16 yrs ago, you'll look back and laugh someday as you serve your family and friends some of the best cookin they've had -- all thanks to this experience.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky