WSM or Egg

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

kettle man

Fire Starter
Original poster
Oct 21, 2012
66
10
North Carolina
I have a Weber Kettle and want something else to smoke on. I can afford the 18.5 inch WSM now. All in the Egg is probably $1400 dollars once you get some acessories. The WSM is 300. Is the Egg worth the wait? Is it that much better than the WSM? The WSM seems more than adequate and priced right. Thoughts from you pros?
 
The kamado cookers are more versitile than the wsm. I like the wsm, but it is only for smoking. If you plan to do other kinds of cooking/grilling, get a kamado. Big Green Eggs are spendy. I recently bought a Kamado Joe. Its practically the same as a BGE, its just a different color. I found one used on Craigslist last week for $450 WITH a plate setter.

Good luck!
 
I feel like my kettle is plenty of firepower for regular cooking. My brother has an Egg and i would love one but man they arent cheap. I feel like the WSM and Kettle are a good combo but dont want to waste $299 if i am going to still need or want an egg.
 
I have the 18.5 WSM and love it my only complaint is now I want the 22".  Get WSM and don't look back.  I have a kettle as well and for bigger cookouts I have grilled several times on the WSM I just pull the center section off and put the grate on the bottom.  

Hope this helps

Aaron
 
Short answer - WSM (and 18" unless you need the extra capacity of the 22" - if you don't, then save the money).

If you could only have "one" to do it all, then the ceramic cooker makes sense.  But since you already have a Weber kettle and are comfortable with that for higher temp grilling, then unless you are going to be limited to only having one grill/smoker due to space, I would go with a WSM in addition to the kettle.

I have a 18" and they did not have the 22" model back when I got mine.  There are pluses and minuses to either, the 22" will require a bigger load of fuel and go through it faster (more volume to keep at temp), but it holds more food and you don't have to cut or coil your ribs like you do in the 18" model. That being said, I am not getting rid of my 18" either.  If price is an issue there is nothing wrong with a 18" WSM unless you really need the extra smoking capacity of the 22". I regularly smoke 4 large pork shoulders at a time in my 18" WSM.  I did 6 once so it can be done (it was a tight fit and I had to stand them on end on both levels).

Also for either a WSM or a ceramic cooker used as a smoker, I would highly recommend a power draft such as the BBQ Guru models.  I have a DigiQ-2 and it makes a long smoke about as close as "set it and forget it" as can be done in a smoker.  It's basically a computer controlled air supply (you block off all the air intakes but the one from the power draft fan).  It either stokes the fire or chokes it back to keep the pit temp at a set point.   I've held 225* for 12 hours without touching a thing in my WSM using the Guru.  Learn how the pit works "as is" first, but at some point go with a power draft (there are several brands out there).  You will not regret it.
 
Last edited:
It does help. I cant justify an egg and feel good with my kettle. Although now i would have a genesis gas grill, kettle and WSM. All in i could have egg but the gas grill is a sunk cost!
 
Short answer - WSM (and 18" unless you need the extra capacity of the 22" - if you don't, then save the money).

If you could only have "one" to do it all, then the ceramic cooker makes sense.  But since you already have a Weber kettle and are comfortable with that for higher temp grilling, then unless you are going to be limited to only having one grill/smoker due to space, I would go with a WSM in addition to the kettle.

I have a 18" and they did not have the 22" model back when I got mine.  There are pluses and minuses to either, the 22" will require a bigger load of fuel and go through it faster (more volume to keep at temp), but it holds more food and you don't have to cut or coil your ribs like you do in the 18" model. That being said, I am not getting rid of my 18" either.  If price is an issue there is nothing wrong with a 18" WSM unless you really need the extra smoking capacity of the 22". I regularly smoke 4 large pork shoulders at a time in my 18" WSM.  I did 6 once so it can be done (it was a tight fit and I had to stand them on end on both levels).

Also for either a WSM or a ceramic cooker used as a smoker, I would highly recommend a power draft such as the BBQ Guru models.  I have a DigiQ-2 and it makes a long smoke about as close as "set it and forget it" as can be done in a smoker.  It's basically a computer controlled air supply (you block off all the air intakes but the one from the power draft fan).  It either stokes the fire or chokes it back to keep the pit temp at a set point.   I've held 225* for 12 hours without touching a thing in my WSM using the Guru.  Learn how the pit works "as is" first, but at some point go with a power draft (there are several brands out there).  You will not regret it.
This is a great suggestion...You already have the Grill. Get the WSM for $400 and then spend the other Grand on...The DigiQ, a Grinder, Sausage stuffer, and a Slicer...JJ
 
I have both the WSM and BGE..

The BGE is ok for a number of things..but I only use it to do steaks...too hard to keep it rolling for smoking..YMMV

I love my WSM with the guru..it is an amazing product..

And dont believe all the bigger is better stuff..

The 18.5 will make plenty for you and most any party you have...  2 turkeys .. 6 butts..etc...
 
wSM seems to have a loyal following. My only fear is pulling the trigger on the WSM and still wanting the Egg. 18.5 inches is what i plan to buy.
 
wSM seems to have a loyal following. My only fear is pulling the trigger on the WSM and still wanting the Egg. 18.5 inches is what i plan to buy.
Dude you know yourself...If you're the guy that has to have the best toys and can spare a Grand at Christmas time, get the Egg. You can always sell the Weber Kettle in the Spring since you won't need it anymore. But if you get the Egg you will have to put in a request to change your Name on the Forum...
biggrin.gif
...JJ
 
Ha. The nickname change is pretty funny. I think i am leaning WSM. Cooked a whole chicken on my kettle last night and cant imagine it would have been better on the egg. I am more interesting in smoking than anything else.:grilling_smilie:
 
I recently got the 18.5 inch WSM. yesterday, I put in 2 racks of ribs and smoked them at 275 degrees. During the entire smoke, the WSM stayed constant at 275. after pulling the ribs out, I left the lid on the WSM. Nearly 5 hours later, the temperature was a little below 275.my point is, the 18.5 is large enough to do multiple meats and using the minion method, you can get constant heat which is nearly set it and forget it. I've not encountered any complaints about the WSM and There's a site dedicated to the WSM that offers great advice. I don't think you'll be disappointed with the WSM.
 
Did you get it local or online? I am in Charlotte as well.
I got mine online--3 weeks ago, Amazon was selling them for $225 or so-man, they sold so fast. 

The ONLY place in Charlotte that sells them is Black's Hardware on Park Road.  They're selling them for $299

Walmart, Home Depot and Lowes are all out of them--trust me, I've been searching.
 
I was in BlackHawk yesterday and they were out. I may get them to order me one or just keep smoking on the kettle until next spring.

Hey man, you have to strike while the iron is hot . I was at Blackhawks 3 weeks ago and they had a few there. I'm sorry you missed it. Today, I did a Puerto Rican Pernil pork on my WSM. is there anything that this baby can't do? In the 3 weeks that I've had it, ive done ribs, pork shoulder, turkey breast and a few chickens.

You could also try Bass Pro Shop in Concord Mills. I saw one a month ago but it was the huge 22 inch, which is a beast.
 
Go with the 22.5".  The 18" is absolutely WSM fantastic...but the 22.5" gives you the ability to do a whole packer brisket and lay three racks flat on the top and 3 flat on the bottom.  You can't do either on an 18".  I just couldn't do the "curl" method for the ribs and "hump it up" method for the brisket.  (Just me I guess)
 
Those are good points.  I went to look at the the 18.5 inch today at a local dealer. She was a beaut. I may keep watching craigslist to get one on the cheap.
 
Go with the 22.5".  The 18" is absolutely WSM fantastic...but the 22.5" gives you the ability to do a whole packer brisket and lay three racks flat on the top and 3 flat on the bottom.  You can't do either on an 18".  I just couldn't do the "curl" method for the ribs and "hump it up" method for the brisket.  (Just me I guess)

While I agree wih you, I will add that the 22.5 may be overkill for some. I saw the 22.5 in person and was shocked at the size of it. I que a lot but for me and many, the 18.5 is a perfect size, which is why it is sold more than the 22.5 inch. In my opinion, bigger is not necessarily better. You can get a lot of cooking done on the 18.5 inch. And, it won't consume as much fuel. I've read that you can reuse fuel on the 22.5 but in my practice, I start fresh n every single smoke.

Regardless of which size you choose, you will get good que.

Finally, kettle man, you posted about watching Craigslist. Unless something was recently posted, you may be wading your time. I was watching Craigslist in Charlotte and surrounding areas for several months. I oly saw 1 posting, in concord. It was a heavily used and rusted 18.5 inch. The seller posted horrible pictures and demanded $225 for it. I got my new WSM For that price plus shipping. These are solidly built smokers so folks don't sell them often. And, as I'm sure you're aware , there are not a lot of great BBQ joints in Charlotte so folks often que at home.

Man, spend that money and get one and get it over with. Also, briskest are on sale this week at the fort mill Walmart.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky