Having troubles with my first Boston Butt smoke

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

jotay21

Newbie
Original poster
Sep 15, 2012
8
10
Sumter, SC(shaw AFB)
Not sure what I am doing wrong, but really getting annoyed at this point.  Threw on three 8lb butts yesterday at about 1300.  Everything was going well at midnight when I went to sleep.  My equipment is a Large Big Green Egg with the stoker hooked onto it for temp stabilization.  At midnight, all was good and meat was sitting about 155* and pit temp holding steady at 225*.  Woke up this morning at 0700 to find that meat was between 171-177*.  Went outside, opened it up and poured in some apple cider into the bowl and shut the lid.  Immediately meat temps started dropping.  They gradually dropped over the next hour and now I have a range of 165-168*.  

Question is if any of you guys have ever seen the temps of the meat actually drop???  I was hoping to hit 205* around 1300 today without foiling.  I have already bumped the stoker to 235* for pit temp and hoping that I don't have to go any higher than that as I would prefer to have them finish up around 1300, pull them off and wrap them in a cooler until around 1500(people are showing up at the house at around 1600).  I am going to hold out without foiling until around 1100 this morning and see where the temp is and then pull them and foil unless any of you guys think I should just call the ball and do it now.  I appreciate any assistance/insight you guys have.

Josh
 
Yes temps can / will drop when you hit a stall. Stay the course . You can foil and hold in an ice chest for 5 - 6 hrs w/ no problems if they get ready to soon. I would recommend that you wait until close to  serving time to pull.
 
On my first Butt the stall nearly killed me I ended up having to throw them into the oven because my offset pit was having some serious ash accumulation issues and I could not keep the temp up. Stay the course they will turn out great!
 
Steadily climbing now.  Back to a range of 174-180* since i posted.  I didn't realize that they could actually drop in temp during the stall.  Just filled the tray one more time with a mixture of water and apple cider.  Pit temp dropped to 178 and stoker had it back to 230 in about 2 minutes.  Seems to be on pace now to easily finish up before people start arriving all without foiling.  We will see though.

Josh
 
Pulled pork takes around 1 1/2 to 2 hours per pound typically. Your butts should've been done by the time you checked it at 7. The only thing I can think of is your smoker temp is off. I hope they turn out well for ya.
 
Josh, welcome to the forum, and thank you for your service.  Hope the problem was solved for you and the smoke turned out and your guests were impressed with your pulled pork.  You got some good info from members, and remember if you need questions answered there are very knowledgeable people here that are willing to share their knowledge.  I have learned a lot here.  Steve
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky