Weekend Winner Smoked Beef Brisket

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

dougmays

Master of the Pit
Original poster
OTBS Member
Nov 18, 2010
2,563
96
Gainesville, FL
So my friend is a Chef and he was having a 3 year annivsery party for his catering business. part of this party was a competition and the categories were Entree, Desert, Side Dish, Appetizer, and Best Overall.

So my plan was the night before slow cook the brikset from 10pm till around sometime in the morning, i had  6lb and 7lb flats. Trimmed most of the fat cap off and i rubbed them down (no fridge time this go around) let them rest to room temp while getting the smoker up to temp.


i haven't used the smoker in awhile and i could not keep the temp down, i guess it was mad at me for neglecting it! so i maintained a 250 degree temp. Threw on the briskets and smoked with oak and cherry. i keep the fat that i trimmed off and lay it on these so the fat still renders down but i can easily remove later. after 3 hours i was going to check the temp and probe to go get a few hours of sleep and realized my meat was already at a IT of 160!!! (there was a post about this haha). so panic begins but i say to myself "well as long as i wrap them and let them rest, and leave the juices in, the moisture shouldn't leave". I let them smoke another hour and a half and get them to ~170

So i let rest for a hour, double wrapped in foil and into the fridge around 2am and off to bed to get up at 8am. i kept in my cooler till about a hour before i was ready to cook them. i brought my Weber kettle to the cookoff to reheat. Put coals on one side and stacked the 2 briskets on the other and began the 2 hour reheat. Right at the 2 hour mark they were up to a nice 170-175, and smelled delicious. other meals had already been served but everyone kept asking where the smoked brisket was. i move over to a small table away from the crown and begin slicing. immediatley a unexpected line forms in front of me so i cut and serve.

i also had made a texas style bbq sauce that turned out great on the meat! this will be my goto sauce for now on for briskets! Now for some Q-View



After the people's choice voting was complete...the winner of the Entree Division....drum roll please....Orange Blossom Honey and Mint Lamb Chops...

SAY WHAT....

i figured i was in the wrong group of people and not refined enough...but then the chef announces the Over all winner..Beef Brisket!

Take that honey-mint lambchops!! (even though they were pretty good)

thanks for watching :)
 
Congrats on the win Doug. That has got to make you smile for sure. Looks like it was tasty too  
 
Awesome Doug......Thats some tasty looking briskey there.......Congrats on the over all... Your braggin rights are welcome.........
icon14.gif

 
 
Doug, LOL......  you thought you were a loser ??...  WRONG.... The brisket looks awesome.... Congrats on the Overall winner....  Dave 
 
Great job. I have never had a brisket go for as long as it seems to take some. Even at low temps 225º or so, my 8 1/2 lb flat was done in 9 hours. Came out great though. Good job Doug.
 
Congrats!

Are you saying you cooked only to 170, put in fridge, and then reheated to 170-175?  

Did it come out juicy and tender?  I thought briskets were suppose to be brought up to around 185-195??  Any reason u did not do that?
 
Congrats!

Are you saying you cooked only to 170, put in fridge, and then reheated to 170-175?  

Did it come out juicy and tender?  I thought briskets were suppose to be brought up to around 185-195??  Any reason u did not do that?
Beef is done at 165...actually for roast beef and more rare you can finish at 145.  The only reason to bring beef (and pork) to higher temps is for the more muscley and fatty meats to break down and be "pull-able". But since i was slicing i didnt need to break down the muscle fibers that much.
 
For the sauce:

1 onion chopped

1 cup ketchup

1 cup worsty sauce

1/2 cup br. sugar

1 cup coffee

1/2 cup cider vinegar

about 6 seranos chopped up

3 tbs chilli powder

5-6 cloves of garlic chopped up

i simmered it all together for about 40 minutes then into the blender to combine and liquify everything (forgot to put a towel over the top and burned my hand!). Then poured the sauce back into the pot and simmered for another hour to thicken up.

the sauce was really spicy at first but i figured the meat would dull it down and it did! super good on the beef! i think next time i might try 2 cups of coffee.

also let refridgerate over night to let flavors combine
 
Beef is done at 165...actually for roast beef and more rare you can finish at 145.  The only reason to bring beef (and pork) to higher temps is for the more muscley and fatty meats to break down and be "pull-able". But since i was slicing i didnt need to break down the muscle fibers that much.
 Beef Temps

Rare  125° - 130°
Medium-rare 135° - 140°
Medium 145° - 150°
Medium-well 155° - 160°
Well done 165° and above

 Obviously Brisket is a tough cut of meat and I do not think a Medium to Medium-rare Brisket would be tender enough.  Has any one ever tried one that low?
  



 
 
Last edited:
Beef is done at 165...actually for roast beef and more rare you can finish at 145.  The only reason to bring beef (and pork) to higher temps is for the more muscley and fatty meats to break down and be "pull-able". But since i was slicing i didnt need to break down the muscle fibers that much.
I've never taken my brisket out that early-I assumed it would be tough.  Is that what you normally do?  Do you probe it for tenderness?  I am curious because I always think my brisket needs more moisture so I wonder if taking it out at a lower temperature is the key.  I usually cook mine  and slow to 190-195 for tenderness-I don't pull my brisket.  I guess it must have been pretty good if you won. 
For the sauce:

1 onion chopped

1 cup ketchup

1 cup worsty sauce

1/2 cup br. sugar

1 cup coffee

1/2 cup cider vinegar

about 6 seranos chopped up

3 tbs chilli powder

5-6 cloves of garlic chopped up

i simmered it all together for about 40 minutes then into the blender to combine and liquify everything (forgot to put a towel over the top and burned my hand!). Then poured the sauce back into the pot and simmered for another hour to thicken up.

the sauce was really spicy at first but i figured the meat would dull it down and it did! super good on the beef! i think next time i might try 2 cups of coffee.

also let refridgerate over night to let flavors combine
Interesting sauce sounds good!
 
Beef is done at 165...actually for roast beef and more rare you can finish at 145.  The only reason to bring beef (and pork) to higher temps is for the more muscley and fatty meats to break down and be "pull-able". But since i was slicing i didnt need to break down the muscle fibers that much.
 Beef Temps

Rare  125° - 130°
Medium-rare 135° - 140°
Medium 145° - 150°
Medium-well 155° - 160°
Well done 165° and above

 Obviously Brisket is a tough cut of meat and I do not think a Medium to Medium-rare Brisket would be tender enough.  Has any one ever tried one that low?
  



 
My first Brisket ......   I loved rare meat..... You could not chew it.... It was cooked on a grate over a fire....  Looked really good..... tasted good..... just couldn't chew it......     Kind of like the first black tailed Jack Rabbit I shot....   even the gravy was tough.....  Dave
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky