Beef short ribs

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

dakota don

Fire Starter
Original poster
Mar 11, 2012
37
10
Beresford South Dakota
My son gave me some beef shortribs to smoke for the 4th.  I have never done these.  Do I handle them like spareribs?  Smoke for so many hours. foil and then finish?   I heard they are tough if not done right.  Please, all information and help will be appreciated.
 
Cook low & slow. Adjust temp depending on thickness, but for thin cut (3/4" - 1"), I have smoked at around 205-210* until I see some shrinkage (around 2 - 2.5 hours), then foiled for another 1.5 hours and finished on open grates for 20-30 minutes. Thicker cuts (~1-1/2") will handle the 225-235* range better.

I like to keep the seasoning a bit more simple with short ribs, mostly black pepper, garlic, onion and a bit of salt. The natural flavors are very good as is, so no need to do much to bring out their best. Smoke with hickory or mesquite is good, cherry and pecan blend should do them justice as well, if you have it.

Eric
 
  • Like
Reactions: dakota don
I have hickory and apple.  Thanks for the advice, these are thick so I will try around 225 to 235. Will follow the hours suggested and what should I look at for internal temp. about 180?
 
With beef short ribs, I agree.  Some here just smoke them, but I have had better luck with foiling and a little liquid in the process.  I call it a "stealth braise".  LOL

Let us know what you do and give us your thoughts?

Good luck and good smoking.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dakota don
Brush with olive oil, season with Kosher or Sea salt, blk pepper, garlic powder, and some onion powder.

Smoke at 225* the 3-2-1 method. Start meat side up, foil with some beer or juice meat side down, remove foil, meat side up and smoke another hour.
 
 
  • Like
Reactions: dakota don
I have hickory and apple.  Thanks for the advice, these are thick so I will try around 225 to 235. Will follow the hours suggested and what should I look at for internal temp. about 180?
You're welcome.

Hickory and apple blend would be a good route to go as well. Apple will add a slightly sweeter back-ground to the sharpness of the hickory...the smoke duration could be a bit longer without it becoming over-powering for the smaller cuts of short rib.

I've never probed ribs for temp, but instead go by shrinkage and pull-pack form the bone. It's a bit tougher to gauge with short ribs, though. If you place the short ribs lengthwise with the wire on the grate, you should see marks from the meat and seasonings where the shrinkage will bare the grate as cooking progresses. This is a good shrinkage indicator for those smaller cuts, as well as brisket and pork butts. If you don't see any signs of shrinkage, it's too early or they're not cooking.

Ribs are a somewhat tougher muscle, so if you were to go by temp and want them tender, probably at least 190*, possibly close to 200*. A bit of poking around should reveal how tender they actually are...less resistance to probing = more tender. Another way to check cooking progress is to lift the meat with tongs and watch for droop (bend test), though this works best for large slabs of ribs, but could also be used for shorties. Less bend = more done (the meat fibers tighten-up as they shrink during cooking, causing the meat to firm-up). With small cuts, when you observe little sag, they're close, if not done.

I had a batch of shorties a few years ago come out of the foil with the bones popping out as I tried to move them back to open grates to set the bark. Probably needed about 20 minutes less time in the foil that time around...super tender eating, still moist, and the texture wasn't mealy/grainy, so, I got away with it that time...LOL!!!

Eric
 
  • Like
Reactions: dakota don
Forluvofsmoke is on point with the tips. The couple times I've done beef ribs. I've basically done them the same way. I love them it's just ashame they don't have a little more meat on them.
 
Beefies don't need the 3-2-1 setup like spares. I kinda look at them like steak. I like mine medium to medium rare so I never do beefies more than 4 1/2 hours. Try marinating them in Mojo Crillio. Outstanding for beef. We rarely see decent racks here, so tend to buy beef backed ribs or short ribs. Sometimes i put them in a pan with some mojo to spoon over them as they smoke. Occasionally rotate the ribs in the pan. For the last 1/2 hour, I remove them and place on the grates.
 

210374ba_BeefShortRibs0065.jpg


2d77b71d_BeefShortRibs0068.jpg


e4d59aa7_BeefShortRibs0069.jpg


1272c754_Draining0010.jpg
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: dakota don
You're welcome.

Hickory and apple blend would be a good route to go as well. Apple will add a slightly sweeter back-ground to the sharpness of the hickory...the smoke duration could be a bit longer without it becoming over-powering for the smaller cuts of short rib.

I've never probed ribs for temp, but instead go by shrinkage and pull-pack form the bone. It's a bit tougher to gauge with short ribs, though. If you place the short ribs lengthwise with the wire on the grate, you should see marks from the meat and seasonings where the shrinkage will bare the grate as cooking progresses. This is a good shrinkage indicator for those smaller cuts, as well as brisket and pork butts. If you don't see any signs of shrinkage, it's too early or they're not cooking.

Ribs are a somewhat tougher muscle, so if you were to go by temp and want them tender, probably at least 190*, possibly close to 200*. A bit of poking around should reveal how tender they actually are...less resistance to probing = more tender. Another way to check cooking progress is to lift the meat with tongs and watch for droop (bend test), though this works best for large slabs of ribs, but could also be used for shorties. Less bend = more done (the meat fibers tighten-up as they shrink during cooking, causing the meat to firm-up). With small cuts, when you observe little sag, they're close, if not done.

I had a batch of shorties a few years ago come out of the foil with the bones popping out as I tried to move them back to open grates to set the bark. Probably needed about 20 minutes less time in the foil that time around...super tender eating, still moist, and the texture wasn't mealy/grainy, so, I got away with it that time...LOL!!!

Eric
Super tender and moist and flavorful.  Sounds like a dream come true rather than a mistake.  Thanks for the advice
 
Thanks,  It sounds like the concensus likes your method.  I am going to go with it.  when mistakes turn out good, I am sold.  Good eating in the Dakotas.  Don
 
Smoked the beef shortrigs by the 3=2=1 method, with the stealth brazing.  Lost track of time because I was waterfighting and swimming with my grandkids.  To say the least they t'urned out very tender and quite moist.  These were very thick rib chunks so It worked out to have them on as long as I did.  Also did some ABTs for the first time, added ranch seasoning with cheese, got good remarks.  Also did two fatties, one sausage eggs etc.  other bacon cheeseburger.  Also turned out very good, watched internal temp to 140 and stayed moist.  I do not do pics well so do well to say I appreciate the advice from forluvofsmoke.  Very slow and low worked great, watched for shrinkage,(and not from being in the pool) and came out great.  Thanks to everyone for the advice it really made our 4th. 
 
Loving this forum and the advice.  Just started smoking this year in an electric smoker.

Having a larger gathering and thawed Beef Short Ribs from two different cows.  Some are only about 1" thick while others range 2-3 inches in thickness.  Should I put them all in the smoker at once, putting thicker ones towards the top and thinner down low?  Or should I put the thicker ones in and maybe an hour later, the thinner?  Plan to use the 3-2-1 method as mentioned.
 
welcome to the forum their is tons of info and lots of knowable people .

if you let us know what smoker you are using it would help a lot.

when you get a minute stop by roll call and tell us a little bit about your self and add your location so people know what part of the country your from 

back to your question ,find the cooler spot on your smoker with a good temp probe and put them there and keep a eye on them

good luck and good smoken
 
I never do them 3-2-1. I do not like beef well done. 4 1/2 hours tops and personally I would start the thicker ones first, then add the thinner ones after an hour or so.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky