2nd Brisket - Following Brisket and Burnt Ends Newsletter

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

effie

Newbie
Original poster
Apr 14, 2012
13
10
Kansas City
This was my second brisket on my smoker... So far it has only smoke 2 briskets, 1 small ham, and some KC Strip Steaks.

For this brisket I mainly followed Jeff's latest newsletter about brisket and burnt ends.  Here is how it went:

Started with a 11.2 lbs packer brisket

5dca5ceb_DSC_2108.jpg


002acb8a_DSC_2109.jpg


Night before I took it out of the fridge and rinsed the brisket.

Then I rubbed the meat side with mustard.

66890634_DSC_2110.jpg


Then coated with Jeff's Rub recipe (meat only, not on fat cap)

ed9b4c9a_DSC_2112.jpg


Next day around 6PM

Soaked Hickory wood chips about 30 minutes, pulled brisket out of fridge while wood chips were soaking.

Then added the wood chips to the bottom of my electric smoker.  Turned on to high and waited about 20 minutes for the smoker to warm up and smoke to start.

Brisket was longer than my 15" diameter grate so I put it down and folder up the thinner "flat" end of the brisket.  Used a metal skewer to hold the meat in that position.  (looks like a monster brisket on that grate)

c1581dc9_DSC_2114.jpg


I planned on a 17 hour smoke, with 2 hours at the end to allow the brisket to rest and for making burnt ends.

Tried cooking around 230-240.  Newsletter indicated 250.  Things cooked faster than expected.  I planned on putting the brisket in foil around 11pm and adding beef broth.  Newsletter did this around 5 hrs in and at 150 internal temp.  I did this at 9:30 (3.5 hrs in) and at an internal temp of 160.

Things progressed somewhat normally except again faster than I planned.  At the rate it was cooking I could of had it ready around 4am instead of 11am.  So I was continually trying to keep it from getting too hot and turning it down more.

Around 2am I went out to add more water to the water pan (had been doing this about every 2 hours) and after filling the pan I heard a hissing... the broth was leaking out of or over the foil "boat"... wish I found a pan that would have worked...

Drained the broth and fat juices into a large measuring cup, added another layer of foil underneath.  Then I re-added the broth... Then when I was trying to scoot it over to put the lid on... the grate somehow slipped up and over making it fall down in the smoker, draining my juices...  you can imagine the thoughts and words I had...  I decided that if I was going to have to add more broth then I would finish it in the oven.  Refoiled, added 2 cups broth, cooked in roasting pan.

Internal temp was still rising faster than desired, so I lowered the oven temp to 200 deg so I could delay it hitting 200 deg internal until sometime between 10 and 11am... worked well.  As I got closer to 9:30/10:00 I turned the over back to around 230.

For all that hassle it came out good.  At 11:30 I pulled the brisket at 199 degrees internal, separated from juices, foiled and let rest 1/2 hour.

Then pulled the brisket out, slid my gloved hand down the fat seam between the point and flat and removed excess fat with glove.

The brisket was extremely tender, so I had to cut up my burnt ends in about 3" cubes.

fac2c2d8_DSC_2115.jpg


bdd7b5fe_DSC_2116.jpg


Then added more of Jeff's rub...

d340959e_DSC_2117.jpg


Rewrapped the flat and put into oven at 190 degrees to hold for a while.

Then put the burnt ends on the grill (per Jeff's #2 option for burnt ends in his newsletter)

0c3dcfac_DSC_2118.jpg


Stirred about every 5 mins and added more rub.

Then before last stirring added some of Jeff's sauce... turned until both sides carmelized.

Brisket was so tender that I was slicing 1/2in and more thick slices... still could not get a 'slice'...

Final Pics

6fbb933b_DSC_2120.jpg


cba77d74_DSC_2121.jpg


756deec3_DSC_2122.jpg


I think next time I might go to an internal temp of 190 to try to get more of a slice

Anybody else have one cook much faster than expected?

Burnt ends were excellent...  You must try Jeff's methods (grill burnt ends in pan), rub, and sauce.
 
Briskets are an interesting creature.  They are all different and some get done faster than others.  Chalk it up to experience.  I am wondering if your cooker temps were higher than you thought.  You might want to ck your thermometer.  Good thing, even though you did not get slices, mistakes still taste pretty darn good!
 
Looks delicious! I did the same thing, cooked a brisket after reading the newsletter. I cooked mine to an internal temp of 197 (according to the probe) I did a boiling water test and found out that my probe was 2 degrees on the high side.  My smoker was running hot for about half the time maybe at 275 and my 8lb brisket finished in 8 hours (so pretty fast, apparently). Anyway, with that I was able to get some really nice slices. I overcooked my ribs, but that's another story.

df26f9a9_2009394560LL.jpg
 
Thanks for the comments!

Bama BBQ,

I was checking my temps with a Maverick ET-732.  This time I had the grate thermo on the back side away from the door.  I may try putting the thermo on the front side and see what is happening.  It could be that the front is hotter than the back.  (The temp on the smoker lid is too far off to use.. +50 degs off of grate temp)

Cab2G,

Your burnt ends look great!
 
Yes briskets are all different.  I've had some real tough ones go up to 17 hours before they were tender and others that were done by dinner time.
 
I have the Master Forge electric smoker. It has an adjustable temperature dial but it is not 100% reliable. No mods yet. Temp probe has a clip to attach it to the grate.
 
Last edited:
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky