Oak or pecan--which is better for smoking meat?

gene pool

Newbie

Original poster

Oct 10, 2011

16

10

• Oct 10, 2011

• #1

This is my first post on this forum.  Today I took possession of a horizontal smoker that the kids at our high school made.  So now I start learning about smoking meat.  Fortunately, I live in the country with lots of timber on the place so wood (green or dead) is no issue.

I have black oak and pecan I was planning on using for smoking.  My question is, which one is better for smoking meat with?

Thank you in advance for your comments.

Gene Pool     

 

JckDanls 07

Legendary Pitmaster

OTBS Member

SMF Premier Member

Sep 10, 2011

8,018

2,652

Tampa area, Florida.

• Oct 10, 2011

• #2

Gene..  first of all..  welcome to the forums..  If you would take a minute to stop over at "roll call' and introduce yourself there first, we would all love to help you..  maybe put a picture in of the smoker the kids built. we would all like to see it. You'll probably want to get a digital probe thermometer (maverick et 732) that way you can monitor the temps of your chamber and your meat...  as you'll find out pretty much everything that is smoked goes by internal temp.

  Don't forget to use the handy dandy "search" tool at the top of the page. Good luck with your new obsession (as you will find out, it is addicting) of smoker cooking.

   As for me...  Pecan is my favorite but you can also use the oak too..  as well as other woods. DO NOT use green wood as it will create to much nasty creasote. DRY WOOD ONLY.

   Really would like to see some pictures (inside and out) and give some details on it as well...

 

tjohnson

Smoking Guru

Moderator

OTBS Member

SMF Premier Member

Insider

Dec 29, 2009

5,600

139

Savage, MN

• Oct 10, 2011

• #3

IMHO, Pecan and Oak are similar, with Oak being a little milder

If you have Pecan, cherish it and enjoy your smoke!

Todd

 

venture

Smoking Guru

OTBS Member

Aug 1, 2008

6,948

73

Central California

• Oct 10, 2011

• #4

Choice of wood often comes down to personal or familial preference.  Try them and tell us what you like!

Good luck and good smoking.

 

roller

Smoking Guru

SMF Premier Member

Mar 10, 2010

6,040

57

N.E. Louisiana

• Oct 11, 2011

• #5

I like pecan  and use it alot...

 

teeznuts

Master of the Pit

Jun 18, 2011

1,065

21

Central Cali

• Oct 11, 2011

• #6

I like pecan and oak, mix em!

 

SmokinAl

SMF Hall of Fame Pitmaster

Staff member

Moderator

OTBS Member

★ Lifetime Premier ★

Jun 22, 2009

51,385

12,221

Central Florida (Sebring)

• Oct 11, 2011

• #7

   Glad to have you with us!

I agree, mix them!

 

flash

Smoking Guru

OTBS Member

Mar 30, 2007

5,280

45

Chiefland/Cedar Key, Fl

• Oct 13, 2011

• #8

Oak is supposedly the second most popular wood to smoke with. Thankfully I have plenty of oak and pecan.

 

slaymaker

Newbie

Dec 24, 2011

9

10

Clarinda, IA

• Dec 25, 2011

• #9

I think Pecan is really good.  The only oak I have used is Jack Daniels chips, which is chipped up oak barrels that were used to age JD whiskey.  Those are awesome!  Really give your meat an interesting flavor.  I have used that for deer and elk jerky, salmon, deer sausage, and even turkey.