Eye Round Roast

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

seaham358

Smoking Fanatic
Original poster
OTBS Member
Aug 18, 2007
765
51
Hyde Park, NY
I've been off of work for a few weeks and I go back Thursday so I figured I'd smoke something before I get busy again.

I have had good luck in the past with Eye round roasts so I figured I'd try another one.  They smoke fast also which is another reason I'm doing one.

36f4861b_P1000125.jpg


A little rub and OO and a couple taters because they are easy and good...

4244764e_P1000126.jpg
 
Holy cow done in 1 hour cooking at 250.. Pulled at 140 and wrapped in foil for 20 min, real juicy and nice flavor.

97f8753b_P1000127.jpg


25ef2ba1_P1000129.jpg
 
Holy cow done in 1 hour cooking at 250.. Pulled at 140 and wrapped in foil for 20 min, real juicy and nice flavor.
Seaham,

Just curious:

After only 1 hour at 250˚, it looks fabulous!!

You said real juicy & nice flavor---I can certainly see that it is nice & juicy, and have no doubt it tastes great.

But---How chewy is it?  I would have thought that cut of meat made that fast would be very tough, and would need to be sliced paper thin.

Thanks,

Bear
 
Seaham,

Just curious:

After only 1 hour at 250˚, it looks fabulous!!

You said real juicy & nice flavor---I can certainly see that it is nice & juicy, and have no doubt it tastes great.

But---How chewy is it?  I would have thought that cut of meat made that fast would be very tough, and would need to be sliced paper thin.

Thanks,

Bear


The eye of round is not a bad cut of meat. I would use more around the 225º area, so that it stayed in the smoker longer and got worked over with the smoke some more. My wife likes to make an Au Jus and dredge the thinly sliced meat thru it, then onto a hoagie roll with cheese, onions, some peppers. Quite tender.
drool.gif
 
Ok I posted to Bear earlier today and it never showed up???

So here it is again..  Bear it was not the most tender piece of meat I ever smoked but I would not call it chewy.  My wife had some and she would have told me in a second if it was chewy (she has in the past).  I did plan on pulling it at 137 like others I have cooked in the past but I missed the thermo going off.  I though I had more time to kill so I was out in the yard with my time killer, Dilligaf

4 month old..

92e11bf8_P1000105.jpg


After playing with the pup I came in and saw the temp was 140 and the thermo was going off.  And I was not unhappy at all with the meat, it was a good med and even with just 1 hour of smoke it had a nice hickory smoke flavor to it. 

Flash I was thinking of cooking my next one at 225, I actually had put that in my note book for my next Eye Round smoke.

For those of you who don't keep a cooking note book of your smokes you should, I find that it helps out alot on improving my smoking technique.

thanks all.. Bob
 
Thanks Flash & Bob,

I didn't mean it's a "Bad" cut of meat. I use it to make dried beef, because it is about as lean as Beef gets.

That's why I figured it would be chewy---Maybe not actually tough, but chewy, especially made that fast.

The reason I asked Seaham (Bob) is because his is cut thicker than I thought I would cut it.

I'm not criticizing---just asking, because it looks very tasty & juicy.

Thanks,

Bear

PS: Good looking pup!!!
 
Bear I didn't take anything in a negative way.. I knew what you meant and I was surprised that it was not tough/chewy. I always cut my meat thick, not sure why? 

Probably because I don't have a Good knife in the house.  I should invest in a good knife and sharpener. And the pup was from the SPCA, got lucky and got a good one :)

If I was a single guys I'd be scoring big time, he's a chick magnet better then a kid I'm thinking. 
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky