As mentioned we had Jeffs and Bilbos. Very different Jeffs is more on the side and Bilbos bringing more of a heat complex. Everyone liked Bilbos but everyone really like all of the combinations. My wife and I were talking tonight and we both think out of all the rubs we have tried we will start to use bilbo as a base and start to modify, starting with a bit more sweet. However i think Jeffs would shine on ribs and bilbos you would not want to "cake" on so much. If I were to rate as is I would give Jeffs a B+ and Bilbos an A. Hey just mixing the 2 together might be perfect, now that I think about it!