SmokingMeatForums.com › Smokers & More › Smokers › Propane Smokers

Propane Smokers

Masterbuilt XL 44 propane smoker

Junk

Travelbilly

Pros: Lots of room, that's it.

Cons: Too many vents and berry poor placement of them as well as their design.inability to maintain constant temps. Need a babysitter.

Bout the version built for cabelas called Masterbuilt Sportsman Elite. Listen, it's supposed to be a smoker, but really, it's grill, no, an oven, that's it. I've used it several times now in order to find the sweet spots as far as operating it, there are none. The least of worries is that the lighter doesn't work, well, it does on one side, but I have to light one side manually. There are so...
(read more)
My first smoker
My first smoker
Decent smoker for the money
Decent smoker for the money
A very good first smoker.
A very good first smoker.

Outdoor Leisure Products Smoke Hollow 38202G

Pros: Roomy with 4 racks. Separate chamber for chips/water pan. Heats quickly. Easy to assemble, good quality materials.

Cons: Heat controls, smoke leakage, inconsistent igniter.

41 Results
Dyna-Glo DGW1235BDP-D 36" Wide Body LP Gas Smoker

Dyna-Glo DGW1235BDP-D 36" Wide Body LP Gas Smoker

“Reposted for David Dunlap by Chef JimmyJ     Right out of the box, testing runs showed two major problems:                                  #1  TEMPERATURE – either too high or too low from intended 225°                       ...” --Chef JimmyJ

0% Positive Reviews
Masterbuilt XL 44 propane smoker

Masterbuilt XL 44 propane smoker

“Bout the version built for cabelas called Masterbuilt Sportsman Elite. Listen, it's supposed to be a smoker, but really, it's grill, no, an oven, that's it. I've used it several times now in order to find the sweet spots as far as operating it, there are none. The least of worries is that the lighter doesn't work, well, it does on one side, but I have to light one side manually. There are so...” --Travelbilly

50% Positive Reviews
Grill Pro 31846 Propane Smoker

Grill Pro 31846 Propane Smoker

“This is my first smoker and I've had some great success with it already.  It was pretty easy to get some good results even on my first runs.  I switched from chips to chunks for the wood and it solved the issue of having the chips burn up too quickly.   ” --samwise

100% Positive Reviews
Smoke Hollow Pro Series 44"

Smoke Hollow Pro Series 44"

“Can you use wood pellets in a Smoke Hollow? If so how? ” --nabor25

91% Positive Reviews
Masterbuilt Two Door Propane Smoker

Masterbuilt Two Door Propane Smoker

“When buying tools, I was taught to buy the best tool you could afford (majority of the time it ends up being the most expensive) it always ends up being an investment in value. I purchased this smoker to try my hand at smoking- not knowing if I would enjoy trying different recipes including smoking. This was a cheaper smoker and I considered this a potential "throw away" tool. After a few...” --4NAP

92% Positive Reviews
Landman USA 3405GW  34" Gas One Door Smoky Mountain Vertical Smoker

Landman USA 3405GW 34" Gas One Door Smoky Mountain Vertical Smoker

“I bought my Smoky Mountain Vertical Smoker back in 2008 at Wal-Mart and was a bit hesitant, because I had always used charcoal smokers, but after discovering how easy to use propane smokers are, I'll never go back.  Like I said, this unit is over 5 years old and still going strong, and I do a lot of smoking.  As far as durability and taste goes, you can't beat it. ” --ArkTraveler

100% Positive Reviews
Smoke Hollow 44241G2 44-Inch Vertical LP Gas Smoker

Smoke Hollow 44241G2 44-Inch Vertical LP Gas Smoker

“I got this smoker because i blew up my last gasser, that's another story. I have since made hot dogs kielbasa, Canadian bacon, venison roasts/jerky/ snack sticks/ hot dogs/ pepperoni, pulled pork, brisket and lunch a few times.  I can get it to hold temps around 115 deg consistently and from there on up.  I burn chunk that I cut from logs, and get 2-3 hours per chunk.  Very...” --MEBeanfarmer

100% Positive Reviews
Masterbuilt Dual-fuel Pro

Masterbuilt Dual-fuel Pro

“ This is one BUTT SMOKING MACHINE. Its very nice do be able to do a 13-15 hour overnight smoke on a big 10lb butt and not have to get up and feed the smoker wood at 3AM, watch temps, etc. The Temp gauge is about 10-15 degrees cooler that actual temp...not a big deal since I use a wireless thermometer with temp warning feature....This is a Home Depot exclusive smoker and is nearly identical to...” --Carl Haun

100% Positive Reviews
Masterbuilt M7P 7-in-1 Smoker and Grill with Pan and Basket Set

Masterbuilt M7P 7-in-1 Smoker and Grill with Pan and Basket Set

“Great first gas smoker (never tried charcoal) if you don't want to spend a lot of money up front. Gets a little cumbersome if you are using more than 1 level. Whole racks will only fit if you roll them (3 will fit rolled). The access to the chip tray is REALLY tight. Best thing to do is move the water bowl to the bottom rack and buy a cheap 3rd rack to still have 2 levels. This way it's much...” --grandmastershek

100% Positive Reviews
Outdoor Leisure Products Smoke Hollow 38202G

Outdoor Leisure Products Smoke Hollow 38202G

“I received the 38' Smoky Hollow with the glass door at Christmas, and have done about 5 smokes so far. The unit is roomy enough to do a 12+ lb. brisket and much more. After two smokes, I ordered a door seal from Amazon, as there was quite a bit of smoke and heat leakage. This one modification has made controlling the heat a bit easier, and no smoke escapes through the door. The smoker heats up...” --csparrazza

100% Positive Reviews
SmokingMeatForums.com › Smokers & More › Smokers › Propane Smokers