Sauce making problems GRRRR!

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

raymo76

Smoking Fanatic
Original poster
Aug 8, 2011
721
37
Ok so I'm absolutely irritated at this, this is the 2n time I've attempted to make sauce. The first one was a Carolina Vinegar sauce, that was supposed to make about a cup and a half, when I finished, it was maybe half of that or less and had a really strong vinegar taste.

No right now I attempted to make a honey-bbq sauce which was supposed to make 1 quart of sauce. I added my cornstarch per the directions and it never quite thickened. Well it reduced to about a cup and a half and does not taste good. It's based on 3 cups of orange juice and 1 cup of lime juice. It taste's very concentrated reminding me of the vinegar flavored sauce.

What am I doing wrong? I hate completely failing at something and this is bugging me immensely!
 
Raymo, I can fix these for you but you have to post the Entire Recipe...Ingredients and at least the amount of time they need to simmer...JJ
 
Last edited:
Ok gimme a sec I don't type that fast. if you have Paul Kirk's Championship BBQ its on pg 145
 
I don't but take your time...JJ
 
1/4 cup olive oil

4 cloves garlic, pressed

1/4 cup minced shallots

3 cups orange juice

1 cup lime juice

1/4 cup clover honey

2 tablespoons peeled & minced ginger

1 tablespoon minced orange zest

1 tablespoon minced lime zest

1 teaspoon fine sea salt

2 tablespoons cornstarch

3 tablespoons cold water

2 - 3 teaspoons hot chile oil, to taste

1. Heat the olive oil in medium saucepan ( i used 3 qt) over medium heat, add the garlic and shallots, and cook, stirring, for 1 - 3 minutes. Add the orange & lime juice, honey, ginger, orange & lime zests, and salt, stirring to combine and bring to a light boil.

2. In a small bowl, blend cornstarch & water with a whisk. Whisk  the cornstarch mixture into the hot sauce (I just dumped it in, big problem?), stirring until the sauce thickens. Remove the sauce from the heat. Stir in hot chile oil to taste.
 
I'd think that sauce would have a bit of a bite to it.  A lot of acid in the sauce and the only thing to calm it down is a small amount of honey.  Not the typical honey BBQ sauce,   Looks more  like a ceviche
 
It's reminding me of a sweet and sour sauce that is heavy on the sour.

I wonder if it would be better with less lime, and more honey.
 
That's where I would go.   I can't see a reason to cook it a long time after the shallots and garlic are clear.  Everything going into the sauce is pretty much ready to eat

Put the cornstarch in a small amount of cold water and stir till smooth.  Whisk into the hot liquids as a thin stream, let cook a minute or two while the liquid thickens.  You may need to practice a bit to find out how much cornstarch is required to get the thickness you want.
 
1/4 cup olive oil

4 cloves garlic, pressed

1/4 cup minced shallots

3 cups orange juice

1 cup lime juice

1/4 cup clover honey   Change to 1Cup Honey

2 tablespoons peeled & minced ginger

1 tablespoon minced orange zest Change to 1tsp Orange Zest

1 tablespoon minced lime zest Change to 1tsp Lime Zest

1 teaspoon fine sea salt

2 tablespoons cornstarch  Change to 4 tablespoons

3 tablespoons cold water  Change to 4 tablespoons

2 - 3 teaspoons hot chile oil, to taste

1. Heat the olive oil in medium saucepan ( i used 3 qt) over medium heat, add the garlic, shallots, Ginger  and cook, stirring, for 1 - 3 minutes or until tender.  Add the orange & lime juice, honey, orange & lime zests, and salt, stirring to combine and bring to a light boil. Reduce heat and Simmer 10-15 minutes to infuse the flavors.

2. In a small bowl, blend cornstarch & water with a whisk. Whisk  the cornstarch mixture into the hot sauce (I just dumped it in, big problem?), Must be whisked or it may lump up,  stirring until the sauce thickens. Remove the sauce from the heat. Stir in hot chile oil to taste. Add additional Honey or Sugar if is not sweet enough.

The original Recipe had a ton of Zest when cooked it can get Really bitter. There was not enough cornstarch in the original and you reduced it way too much. I suspect your heat was too high and Boiled too long...2-3 Tablespoons of Tomato Paste will smooth the flavor without making it really tomato flavored. I would add 1 Tablespoon of Soy Sauce as well. I hope this helps you...Good Luck...JJ
 
Last edited:
That almost sounds more like a marinade than a bbq sauce . Whole lot o citrus. Imho , It may benefit w/ some brown sugar added to it.

 Corn starch slurry needs to come to a low boil while being stirred to achieve its maximum thickening ability.
 
icon_cool.gif


I'm with AL and this almost looks like a ceviche with all of that citrus. Now JJ's fixes look an sound better. heck give it a shot.
 
As usual, I would bet JJ has you right on.  Cornstarch can be a delicate thickener in this type of preparation.

Good luck and good smoking.
 
Thanks Chef! I'll give that a whirl. I just got done cleaning my utensils so I might give it a whirl tonight or another day this week, but I really appreciate the help!

I know I boiled it too long trying to get it to thicken up. I want to try it on some BB Ribs.
 
You might also cut back the amount of olive oil..... a full 1/4 C is usually way more than I use in any sauce. I usually just use enough to sautee the veg in.
 
You might also cut back the amount of olive oil..... a full 1/4 C is usually way more than I use in any sauce. I usually just use enough to sautee the veg in.
Good Call!...I missed that one, 2 Tbs Oil will be plenty...JJ
 
Last edited:
Thanks Chef! I'll give that a whirl. I just got done cleaning my utensils so I might give it a whirl tonight or another day this week, but I really appreciate the help!

I know I boiled it too long trying to get it to thicken up. I want to try it on some BB Ribs.
Any time Ray, that what we are all here for...You may find when you refrigerate leftover sauce that it sets up like Jello from the Starch, just warm it over low heat and you will be Golden...JJ
 
 
Well I got it cooling off now. I think the lime's either need to be cut it half or gone. I did not have any tomato paste on board but I ended up using about 7 ounces or so (roughly half a 15oz can) of tomato sauce. I still added more honey and I used the tablespoon of soy sauce. Overall a lot better. Still has a lil zip to it and I think that's coming from the limes. It's got a nice orange flavor, I'm not sure if I want the honey to be subtle or not. So for now I'm just letting it cool and we'll see how it tastes on some ribs.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky