No smoke ring!!!! Whats the dealio?

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

lspilot82

Meat Mopper
Original poster
Nov 30, 2009
162
11
Lakeland Florida
Hey guys the last couple times I've done some ribs I havent been able to produce a smoke ring...it baffles me. They seem to have plenty of smoke flavor and boy aren't they good, but they have had no smoke ring. So what could the problem be? I give them plenty of smoke and have plenty of water in the pan...so if anyone knows any tricks of the trade please share. Thanks.
 
What kind of smoker are you using? It's my understanding that Electric Units don't produce a Smoke Ring...JJ
 
So there you go...If you are doing a hotter Smoke and the Wood Chips/Chunks combust, you will get a little bit if a ring but in general with Electrics you just get good smoke flavor.

I have heard from people that say, "In a Blind Taste Test...Ring..No Ring...I can't tell the difference in Flavor."...Anybody Here do a comparison?...JJ
 
Try putting a piece of lump or a briquette in with your wood chips and see what happens.  That worked for me on my MES.  But, I went back to a charcoal smoker for this exact reason.  I believe there is better flavor that way.  Everyone has their own preference...
 
A smoke ring can be obtained in an electric smoker by adding in charcoal while smoking.

The question is whether or not you can taste the smoke ring.

The answer is no, so why fuss about it?

If it taste good to you eat it and don’t worry about it.
 
I agree that there is probably no difference in taste.  

However, you eat with your eyes first, so there is probably a perceived difference when you see the ring.
 
Ok thats awesome...so for aesthetics and for the beauty of a smoke ring, add a bit of charcoal...I think I'll do just that. Thanks fellas.
 
Be careful adding charcoal.

With electric smokers it is possible to over smoke your food.  

As to the aesthetics is it really worth the risk of messing up an otherwise good recipe?

I mean really, isn’t life too short to sweat the small things?  
th_dunno-1%5B1%5D.gif


Just my $0.02
 
I always add a few pieces of charcoal to my chip pan in my MES30 through out the whole cook time and then you get a nice smoke ring.  I think people eating it really appreciate the look of the food THEN the taste!

Brian
 
Last edited:
I find that ribs will take on more of a ham flavor with a smoke ring, whether that's good or bad is up to the individual.
 
"The smoke ring is caused by nitric acid building up in the surface of meat, absorbed from the surface. This nitric acid is formed when nitrogen dioxide from wood combustion in smoke mixes with water in the meat. Basically it is a chemical reaction between the smoke and the meat." Smoke rings no longer hold any value in competition bbq events because it can be artificially created with Morton's Tender Quick.  Hope this helps! Keep on smokin!!!
 
Be careful adding charcoal.

With electric smokers it is possible to over smoke your food.  

As to the aesthetics is it really worth the risk of messing up an otherwise good recipe?

I mean really, isn’t life too short to sweat the small things?  
th_dunno-1%5B1%5D.gif


Just my $0.02
      X2     Add my 2 cents 

 
 
Be careful adding charcoal.

With electric smokers it is possible to over smoke your food.

As to the aesthetics is it really worth the risk of messing up an otherwise good recipe?

I mean really, isn’t life too short to sweat the small things?
th_dunno-1%5B1%5D.gif


Just my $0.02
X2 Add my 2 cents 
 

I don't know if there is difference in taste. but you maneged get from the guys 4 cents
biggrin.gif
 
 
what kind of rub are you using? if your using one with alot of sugar (brown or white) your rub might be carmalizing to quickly and sealing up the meat from absorbing smoke....just my assumption?

if you do use alot of sugar try Turbinado (sp?) sugar....higher melting point

my 2 cents
 
Good info SQWIB.

I have a friend who is a KCBS competitor and judge.

He tells me that the size of, or lack of a smoke ring cannot be used during judging because the smoke ring can be easily manipulated.

It isn't that the electrics don't produce a smoke ring, as some have suggested, but rather that the small amount of wood used that turns into charcoal, and then to ash, doesn't produce enough nitrates to penetrate into the meat.

If you want a nice smoke ring, just do what the KCBS rules were promulgated to prevent Simple sprinkle a little Cure #1 on the surface of the meat and let sit for about 15 min.

Then rinse off and apply your rub.

The additional nitrates will then penetrate and give you a nice pink ring.

This may end up, as Dan said, adding a hammy taste
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky