MES 30" or 40" ???

Discussion in 'Electric Smokers' started by slosmoke, Mar 5, 2008.

  1. slosmoke

    slosmoke Fire Starter

    Was planning on going to Cabellas and pick up the 30" SS unit for $250.Friend of mine calls me and says Sams has a 40" for $299.So give me the low down on which one to get.And no I am not gonna get both.Thanks
  2. lawdog

    lawdog Smoking Fanatic

    Get the 40", I tried to save alittle money and ordered the 30" and my boss has the 40". Hands down if I could do it over agin I would have gotten the one from Sam's. IMO

  3. djohn312

    djohn312 Fire Starter

    I also have the 30 and wish I would have gotten the 40 just need more space
  4. desertlites

    desertlites Master of the Pit OTBS Member

    thats a ongoing topic in here-ALWAYS go bigger than the 1 you Were looking at.
  5. davenh

    davenh Smoking Fanatic OTBS Member

    I have the 40" and it suffers some in the winter time. The 30" and 40" have the same heater, it is better sized for the 30". In warmer weather it shouldn't be that significant. If your in a cold climate and want to use it on a cold day the 40 could take longer than the 30 to reach temps. At least that what I see with my 40" MES.
  6. psychobrew

    psychobrew Smoke Blower

    I agree with the downside, but my 40" always reaches temp in freezing weather (as long as I don't open the door). On the other hand, the 40 might smoke better since the element has to work harder.
  7. slosmoke

    slosmoke Fire Starter

    So the 30" and 40" have 4 racks in both units and the heater is the same size in both .Only diff is the height ? Someone gave me a product # for the 40" SS at Sams 916979.So I will give them a ring and see if they have this beast in stock.
  8. davenh

    davenh Smoking Fanatic OTBS Member

    I think the 40" may also be wider by about 6" or so. A full slab of ribs fits on fine the rack.
  9. mossymo

    mossymo Master of the Pit OTBS Member SMF Premier Member

    I have the 30" and the 40", if I had to choose one of the two I would say the 40". But I do like having both; I believe Illini has both also. Hopefully he will be along shortly to get his thoughts on this.
  10. kurtsara

    kurtsara Smoking Fanatic OTBS Member

    I bought the 30" black smoker to save a little money in the begining, but now I spent another $350.00 and the 40" should be here Thursday.

    I wanted a second smoker thought about a stick burner but ended up ordering the 40" on Sunday
  11. illini

    illini Smoking Fanatic OTBS Member

    The latest 40" MES comes with a very nice cover included......they are currently $299 at Sam's....thanks again MossyMo for the heads up.....

    If I only were to have one it would be the 40" but the 30" is a very spirited little smoker and superior for some of your smoking endeavers.....

    The 40 can be a little short on heating up at times....DaveNH and others have been adding a little charcoal with the wood and have reported exciting results.......Like a smoke ring!!

    The cooking grates are the same depth...about 6" wider which is a major advantage....the vertical height between grates is almost double.......Cant beat the size difference for functionality
  12. slosmoke

    slosmoke Fire Starter

    So I gave a call to Sams and the woman there tells me that they had 7 units on Sunday.Tuesday it went down to 4.So now they have 3.I just got back from there with the new 40".I might not get it plugged in till this weekend.Sold for $ 299. and it did come with a cover.Thats about it for now.Thanks for the help.
  13. davenh

    davenh Smoking Fanatic OTBS Member

    Damn..I got the 2007 model at Sams, no cover. Called Masterbuilt to ask about the cover and they don't have any. Make sure to look at the boxes before you grab one because there are old models and new models mixed in there. Probably leftovers from last year. The Club near me is still selling the 2007 model for $299.
  14. I am the new owner of a 30" black mes. Really Really considered getting the 40" from Sam's.

    BUT, the nearest Sam's club to me is approx 40-50 miles, and I am not a member which would cost me a little as well.

    They have them in stock and I was really tempted. Figured the 30" was a good place to start. Only done 1 smoke and am already loving it. Bought a bradley cover for about $25 from amazon for it was well.

    But I can definitely see a 40" mes in my future!

  15. mossymo

    mossymo Master of the Pit OTBS Member SMF Premier Member

    Congrats on the new MES !!!
    I have said it before and I will say it again, there is no such thing as too many smokers; right tool for the right job. (I sure hope my wife doesn't read this !!!).
  16. geob

    geob Meat Mopper SMF Premier Member

    You will like the 40 MES. I have the 30 MES and have no heat recovery proplem in Mississippi. Just don't get that cold here.

    The only thing I see is wrong with the 30 is you can't find jerky trays that fit. I had to make mine.
  17. allen

    allen Smoking Fanatic

    I bought a 40" SS MES and really enjoy it, the problem I had was getting the Temp up where I wanted it and keeping it there
  18. smoked

    smoked Master of the Pit OTBS Member

    I think the only problem with the "bigger" MES is that it still uses the same heating element....... I'd still buy one if I could find one here....but I'm happy with my MES I have now as is..... [​IMG]
  19. erain

    erain Master of the Pit OTBS Member SMF Premier Member

    i was in sams sat b4 easter and was lookin at the 40 incher, i have a GOSM already but was thinking for times when i really didnt want to have to keep that close a watch on it that this would be the ticket. needless to say i picked one up monday, havent taken it out of the box yet. but as i been reading posts on the MES i see noted alot that they donot leave any smoke ring. is this purely cosmetic or do the electrics have a disadvantage over others. been thinking about it and cant see how it would differ from the gas job. just different sources of heat,still suppling the smoke. so if anyone has anything to this smoke ring absence in the MES would like to hear about it. like i said still in box so have been contemplating returning it but if i hear positive i would keep it. i also paid $299.00. thks
  20. irwinwd

    irwinwd Smoke Blower


    Ilini and I had a whole conversation about the smoke ring or lack there of with the electrics last year. I have been very happy with my MES over the past 15 months, but couldn't help but notice that I could not generate the smoke ring shown in many posts. It does seem to be an issue of air flow, smoke generation (volume) an potentially other factors.

    My food has alway had a good smoked flavor and is visaully applealing, just lacks the ring. The end conclusion was, if you are entering a competition the lack of smoke ring would knock you out of the running. If you are looking for good food and an easy way to regulate temperature, this unit is great.

    I have the 30" in black btw. I have yet to make bad food in my MES and that statement goes a long way in my book.

Share This Page