How do I cook a 20 lb pork shoulder on my Traeger?

Discussion in 'Roll Call' started by the real griz, May 19, 2016.

  1. I was given a traeger recently and also a 20lb piece of meat that I believe is a boneless pork shoulder. I want to cook one on the other but am unsure how hot and fo how long to go about this. I have read people that say nearly 2 hours per pound but should I really have it on for as long as 40 hours? I dont want to mess it up, Can someone please help me?
  2. smokinal

    smokinal Smoking Guru Staff Member Moderator OTBS Member ★ Lifetime Premier ★

    Are you sure it's not a 2 pack, with 2 - 10 lb pieces?

  3. Good question. It's in shrink wrap but I'll have to check. Either way, what are some good ground rules for cooking this piece of meat on a traeger?
  4. seenred

    seenred Smoking Guru Group Lead OTBS Member

    Hi Griz...

    First off, welcome aboard!  Congrats on that new Traeger!  There's nothing much easier to operate than a pellet smoker.  Just fill the hopper with pellets, set the temp and go! 

    I was gonna ask the same thing Al asked...many times, those big cryo-packed pork shoulders are actually 2 pieces of roughly equal weight.  If it turns out that it's actually one whole hunk of meat, I'd suggest going ahead and cutting it in half.  Much easier to handle and cook two 10 lb. roasts than one 20 pounder.  This also drastically reduces the overall cook time...figure your time estimate based on 10 lb. hunks.

    The rule of 2 hours per lb. is a reasonable guess for your first cook, depending on your cooking temp.  At a "low and slow" temp of 225*, it may well take between 1.5 and 2 hours per raw pound of meat to get it done.  Obviously, the hotter you cook, the more time you can subtract from that estimate.  I generally cook pork butts (shoulders) in the 250-275* range myself...but I'll still allow around 1 - 1.5 hours per pound so I'm not rushed to get it on the table by serving time.  I actually prefer to smoke pork butts a day or 2 ahead of time and reheat the day of...pulled pork reheats very well.

    For your first try, I'd suggest keeping it as simple as you can...apply a healthy coating of your favorite pork rub, get it in the smoker, and let 'er ride.  Some folks like to mop or spritz the meat at least once an hour, but I find it unnecessary with pork butts...and every time you lift the lid on that Traeger, you add more time to the cook by allowing heat (and smoke) to escape.  

    With a pork shoulder, don't concern yourself too much about how long it takes.  Many of us say "it gets done when it gets done."  Be more concerned about the meat's internal temperature (IT).  If your don't already own one, get yourself an accurate meat probe thermometer.  Your target IT for that shoulder is about 200* if you plan to make pulled pork out of it.  Once it reaches the target temp, let it rest under a foil tent on your counter or in a cool oven until it has cooled enough that you can handle it without burning yourself (this may take an hour or longer), then just use your hands to pull the tender meat apart.

    Many guys will then apply some kind of finishing sauce, although I personally usually don't.  Here is a link to a very popular one:

    I know that's a lot of info to take in all at once...hope it helps!

    Good luck!  And remember...we love to see pics of others' cooks!

    Last edited: May 19, 2016
  5. SeenRed, thank you very much. That is exactly what I needed. I need to get one of those thermometers that I can simply leave in the meat for the duration but I should be okay to start off.
    Understanding the necessary IT is great, I mostly wanted to know what to expect for time so that I would know when to have it in by, or when I could expect to be able to eat. Thank you for welcoming me here, and for your advice. I will post pics when it's done!

Share This Page