Choosing a better SMOKER><><><INPUT?

Discussion in 'Messages for All Guests and Members' started by chubbs, Dec 20, 2007.

  1. chubbs

    chubbs Fire Starter

    I was in the local Gander MTN. today and saw that they had the Smoky Mountain 30in. electric for $99.

    The 34in. propane was $130.

    I'm looking to upgrade from the Big Chief so I can do larger meats and not just jerky. Would the propane be the better way to go?
  2. walking dude

    walking dude Smoking Guru SMF Premier Member

    you have a LOCAL Gander MTN.?
  3. smokebuzz

    smokebuzz Master of the Pit OTBS Member

    Dude we got 1 in CR..
  4. richtee

    richtee Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    HArd to tell...he's kinda quiet about his location. Maybe he's my neighbor... got one 30 min. from here.
  5. chubbs

    chubbs Fire Starter

    It is in Rochester, NY...I know I need to take a few minutes to do my profile.
  6. walking dude

    walking dude Smoking Guru SMF Premier Member


    what the h*ll is wrong with the LARGEST city in the GREAT STATE OF IOWA???????
  7. richtee

    richtee Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    Alphabetical or numerical order?
  8. smokebuzz

    smokebuzz Master of the Pit OTBS Member

    Where shall i start?
  9. chubbs

    chubbs Fire Starter

    So now that I did my profile...and started the Iowa Debates....can I get a smoker opinion?
  10. smokebuzz

    smokebuzz Master of the Pit OTBS Member

    Caucas is Jan. 3rd
  11. richtee

    richtee Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    OK NY... cold. Propane, or a honker electric. I mean if ya don't have the room/space patience for a stickburner anyway.

    But seriously, anything is an improvement over the LC in the seriousQ dep't. You know their capabilities, and it ain't enuff.

    The true art demands stick/coals burning as near as I have acertained. But it's a P I T A. I have an ECB, and can do anything...slightly less painfully than a stick rig.

    The propanes are an improvement in temp management/maintainance, and sheer BTUs for cold weather.

    The electrics have good temp control, but ya best consider your location and get a heavy KW unit. and..look to your left for more info...that menu on the main screen.
  12. kew_el_steve

    kew_el_steve Smoking Fanatic OTBS Member

    Where's Iowa? Is that where all the potatoes are grown? Is it cold there?

    Seriously, Decide what fuel you want to use and what you want to spend, and do some searches on the threads. This is debated endlessly. A better smoker can mean anything from a UDS to a GOSM to an offset stick-burner to a BGE to a Stumps to a Backwoods to a Southern Pride. I covered the range from $100 to $10,000. So what is better? Depends on you!!!

    Go Pats...
  13. chubbs

    chubbs Fire Starter

    Thanks, but I only wanted to know what was better between the 2 I listed.

    I think I would prefer the gas one. Especially in this climate.
  14. richtee

    richtee Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    Get the one with the beer holder.
  15. lcruzen

    lcruzen Master of the Pit OTBS Member

    I can relate to your issue. I have a Big Chief and it has just sat idle since I got my propane GOSM. Holds a good steady temp in cold weather, has enough capacity to feed a big crowd if needed.

  16. virgo53

    virgo53 Smoke Blower

    Gas one I find is easier to use, The comments about the others are valid
    your explained situation, from my experience indicates a propane unit.

  17. fritz

    fritz Meat Mopper

    I say go with the gaser. I have a GOSM and it works great in Rochester. Get the widest one they got.

    Oh...We have a Gander in Rochester.[​IMG]
  18. chubbs

    chubbs Fire Starter

  19. brianj517

    brianj517 Master of the Pit OTBS Member SMF Premier Member


    My vote definitely is for the propane unit. I live in NE Ohio, and I would assume a very similar climate. I actually own two GOSM gassers, (both sizes 'cause I quickly outgrew the smaller one once I recognized and came to terms with my addiction [​IMG] ). Propane allows me to regulate temps much more easily during the colder months.

    FYI; Be very careful with the Walmart unit...I have seen many that are very thin walled and flimsy. Both my units came from Gander Mtn and are far more sturdy. In fact, my "youngest" is ready to celebrate the beginning of her fourth season around March and she still puts out some of the finest stuff around and looks real purty doin' it!

  20. brianj517

    brianj517 Master of the Pit OTBS Member SMF Premier Member

    An addendum...

    By the way, Chubbs, as others have stated, a stick burner is THE way to go for question about it. In fact I am looking into upgrading to one myself this spring. But for convenience and control, based on the two models you mentioned in your original post, my suggestion is the GOSM gasser from Gander Mtn.


Share This Page