5 lb. chuck - view

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

guvna

Smoking Fanatic
Original poster
May 25, 2008
345
10
Fairfax, VA
hey guys and gals,
i haven't posted in a while 'cause i just bought a house and blah, blah, blah... here's the chuck. i'm trying something different today in light of the "foil - no foil" and "mustard - no mustard" questions. generally, i use mustard and then foil at 170*. today, no mustard, no foil, using a peach/pecan combo and smoking @ 240*. i'm expecting this to take a lot longer to reach the deisred temp, but my theory is better bark will result. i'll post my findings in due time.
 
You're off to a good start my friend. keep us posted.
 
I'm eager to see the results too. I've done butts and ribs with and without foil but all my chuckie's have been foiled.
 
here it is 4 hours in.
i just hit it with a modified (added cayenne pepper sauce) soflaquer's sauce. i had some red potatoes laying around so i threw those on there as well.
 
That's a good looking chuck. Thanks for the Qview.
 
Looks real good. I have 2 in the freezer and might just be smoking one up this weekend
PDT_Armataz_01_37.gif
 
good lord! i'm over 12 hours in now and the meat is holding steady at 174*. i'm pretty drunk now and my mouth is watering... be strong GUV, be strong.............
 
Good things come to those that wait and great things come to those who wait even longer. Looks great so far.
 
Wait...wait...wait for the signal...

Looks and sounds great...patience, and the reward will be a crazy good meal!

Eric
 
well, it's 1:17am now and the meat has been at 186* for an hour... but i won't let it win, damn it!!! i can wait. i don't know how much longer though
confused.gif
confused.gif
confused.gif
 
okay,
i ended up pulling it out at 195* at about 4:15 am (19 hours). i think that most of the reason it took so long was that i had a few temp issues nearing the finish line. first i ran out of propane, then i hooked up a different empty tank i had laying around, by the time i got the third tank hooked up the meat had already dropped in temp from 188* to 185*. it took a long time to recover from that mishap. in addition, it got really cold here last night and snowed this morning so every time i turned around the smoker was losing precious degrees by the tens! any how, i took it out, wrapped it in foil and a towel, put it in a cooler and went to bed. my initial thoughts are this: the meat most definitely has a better (dry-er) bark. some pieces of the meat are down-right burnt ends! i couldn't really tell a big difference in the mustard controversy though. the meat had shrunk substantially from raw (by half, maybe), and was more dry than when i use foil. one thing is for sure... it's REALLY good! the bottom line? i think i'll be foiling large meats from now on, and i kinda like the mustard even if you can't taste it. if i we're to do this over again, i would rub with mustard, smoke to 175* then foil. i think that would be a happy medium for the bark/time/juicyness ratio.
thanks for watching
-guvna
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Clicky