Some Sirloin Tip for sliced roast beef sammie :-)

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

demosthenes9

Master of the Pit
Original poster
OTBS Member
Apr 2, 2013
1,438
142
Louisville, KY
Whole Sirloin Tip was on sale this week so I got some.   Here's 4 tips that have been halved and tied into  8    3 - 4 lb roasts.   Yummmm.


Here's 4 more tips that were also halved and tied into 8   3 - 4 lb roasts.   Double Yummmmmmmm.


Here's all 16 of them in a group shot.


Rubbed them down with some EEVO then coated with some coarse ground pepper and kosher salt.   Nothing fancy, then again, no need  to be.

Here's all 16 hanging out in my Smoke Hollow 44 just waiting to be bathed in some Hickory, Cherry and Oak (Todd's Pittmaster's Blend.)


You might only see 8 at first glance, but if you look close you can see that there are 4 roasts per rack.

Smoker was rolling along at 240ish before I put the meat in.  As you might guess, putting in that much cold thermal mass seriously dropped the chamber temp.  It went down to 150ish.    I loaded 4 roasts at a time and kept the door closed in between trips back into the house to get the next 4.

Plan is to take them all to about 125ish, then foil and wrap.   Not going to do a mass removal, instead, like with good bourbon, I will check each one individually and pull when they hit the desired temp.   

More pics to follow  
drool.gif
 
Last edited:
 
Nice collection of beef - that will be a lot of good eating 
thumb1.gif
  This should be a good smoke so I'll follow along 
smile.gif
  Are you using hickory, cherry & oak or hickory, cherry & maple?
It's Pittmaster's Choice from Todd at Amazen, and iirc, it's Hickory, Oak and Cherry.    Guess I forgot to mention that I'm using 2 AMNTS's in my propane smoker.
 
Its hickory, maple and cherry. I use it alot.
 
Whew, just had a freaking panic attack.     Some of my Mavericks gave me some false readings, telling me that some of the roasts were already over 150 degrees  
icon_mad.gif
 
icon_cry.gif
 .

Cussed a whole bunch then took a close look at the loins in question.  Too light, too soft and too jiggly for something that was supposedly that high.   Pulled the probe from my latest Maverick and checked each of the loins, and it showed them to be around 100 degrees.     PHEW.

Weirdest thing is that I did the boiling test on my older Mavericks recently and all of them registered 210 - 212 !!   Go freaking figure.
 
 
It's Pittmaster's Choice from Todd at Amazen, and iirc, it's Hickory, Oak and Cherry.    Guess I forgot to mention that I'm using 2 AMNTS's in my propane smoker.
Its hickory, maple and cherry. I use it alot.
 
Yup that's why I was wondering - there is another place that sells a mix that is hickory, oak & cherry but it's not called Pitmaster's Choice. Just wanted to be sure - it should be smelling pretty good around your place 
smile.gif
Damn, I SWEAR Todd's website used to say Hickory, Oak and Cherry   :).

I just double checked after reading these posts and sure enough, it says Hickory, Cherry and Maple plain as day. 
30.gif
 
Holy Moly, why 16 roasts!  Who you cookin' for?  Can't wait to see one of them sliced!  Hrm maybe my Bandera could squeeze in 16 roasts.. maybe not lol.  That's a lot!
 
Last edited:
 
Holy Moly, why 16 roasts!  Who you cookin' for?  Can't wait to see one of them sliced!  Hrm maybe my Bandera could squeeze in 16 roasts.. maybe not lol.  That's a lot!
It's an efficiency thing.  I don't like to fire up the smoker to just cook 1 or 2 of something, so I mention to some people (or on Facebook) that I'm going to be smoking whatever and people ask me to smoke some for them as well.

With these roasts, I'll chill them in the fridge tonight and then break out my slicer tomorrow.   Once they are all cut, I'll vac pack 1 lb per bag and people can come and pick them up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: smoking b
 
It's an efficiency thing.  I don't like to fire up the smoker to just cook 1 or 2 of something, so I mention to some people (or on Facebook) that I'm going to be smoking whatever and people ask me to smoke some for them as well.

With these roasts, I'll chill them in the fridge tonight and then break out my slicer tomorrow.   Once they are all cut, I'll vac pack 1 lb per bag and people can come and pick them up.
That's very cool! I wish I had more friends like that to have an excuse to load up my Bandera and tend a fire all day.
 
Last edited:
Smoker was rolling along at 240ish before I put the meat in.  As you might guess, putting in that much cold thermal mass seriously dropped the chamber temp.  It went down to 150ish.    I loaded 4 roasts at a time and kept the door closed in between trips back into the house to get the next 4.
I guess if I were to load my Bandera like that I'd crank up the fire with many small splits right?  Maybe it wouldn't drop too much.  Is your smoker 230V or 110V?  I wonder how many more BTU's the Bandera can put out compared to the Smokey Hollow.
 
Last edited:
 
I guess if I were to load my Bandera like that I'd crank up the fire with many small splits right?  Maybe it wouldn't drop too much.  Is your smoker 230V or 110V?  I wonder how many more BTU's the Bandera can put out compared to the Smokey Hollow.
Yeah, that should do it.   Next time I load mine with this much, I'll probably preheat to over 300 and then adjust as needed.     It's a propane smoker with dual 12K BTU burners.  Have no idea how as to how many BTUs the Bandera can reach.
 
Last edited:
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky